Recently there has been all sorts of controversy regarding Valves acquisition of the DotA property and even more so the announcement of Defense of the Ancients 2 (DotA 2). There does not appear to be a centralized website for the game thus far, but there are enough articles to keep you busy until then if you Google it. Now it is my turn to add to that list…
Personally I think Valve is making a mistake by trying to create a sequel for the game, or even bothering with the IP in the first place. Valve has been known for their original properties and revolutionary thinking, and while DotA did establish a genre we are only beginning to see utilized Valve has the brainpower and resources to do far better.
To be fair, all we have seen is artistic renderings of the game’s characters and mention that the game will hold true to the original mechanics. Is that really so bad? I don’t think that is terrible, besides Valve has plenty of time to clean it up and make it better, I mean that has been Riot’s intention from the start. Consider the second FPS ever made, it was probably not all that different than the first, and if you look at the latest FPS there are plenty of similar qualities. So as long as there is progression I don’t think there is anything to get to worked up over.
What appears to be the greater issue for most people is Valves association with IceFrog, whom apparently does not have the best reputation in the DotA community. I have never worked with the guy and despite the stories I head about him while working at Riot I really cannot judge. But still, Valve could have done all of this without him or the DotA title. Lets just hope they take DotA (not a terrible game) and really make it their own (a great valve game)!